The prospect of comparing the Porsche 911 to a Chevrolet Corvette would have seemed absolutely preposterous before the eight generation of the American sports car was introduced, and some people might raise an eyebrow even now, despite the fact the C8 has had its engine moved behind the cabin.
The thing is, it’s just as likely to get an incredulous reaction from people on both sides. On the one hand, you’ll get the 911 purists who look at the Corvette and think it lacks the elegance and refinement to be put into the same category as their favorite vehicle, and they’re somewhat right; on the other hand, you get the Corvette faithful who glance at the 911 Carrera’s power output and specs and scoff since they’re considerably below the C8, and they too are somewhat right.
So, is there even a point in comparing these two? Well, if you go crazy when specifying the equipment on the C8 and add the dealership markups as well, these two end up costing pretty much the same (just over $100,000), which means that they could technically fight for the same segment of the market.
That being said, just by looking at these cars, you instantly know you’re getting two very different packaged. The Porsche 911 Carrera is this smooth, curvaceous machine that’s just as graceful as it is sporty; the Corvette is quite the opposite, trying to poke your eyes out with every sharp angle of its body and making no excuses about it.
It’s the same story inside. RacerX, the man performing the review, says the 911’s cabin “doesn’t feel like it has a ton of bell and whistles.” Well, that’s called subtlety, and the Porsche has it in abundance. Don’t forget the 911 is just as much a GT as it is a sport car. As for the passenger cup holder, it actually pops out from under the right-most vent.
Photo: RacerX / YouTube screenshot
If Porsche’s interior is somewhat subdued and on the minimalist side, the C8’s is the exact opposite. You feel like it’s screaming at you. There’s plenty of silver plastic that makes it look cheap, and the abundance of color on the displays gives it a toy-like feel. Apart from that, though, it does do a very good job at making the driver feel as though they’re the most important person in the car with the angled dashboard and the almost comically high divider separating them from the passenger.s
With a 3.0-liter twin-turbocharged flat-six that makes 379 hp and similar weight, it’s hard to imagine how the Porsche could stand any chance compared to the 6.2-liter V8 and the 495 hp it makes for the Corvette. That’s a gap of well over 100 hp, but one the 911 Carrera manages to appear a lot smaller thanks to its traction control system and supreme eight-speed PDK transmission. The similar unit (eight-speed dual-clutch) in the C8 does an equally good job and the overall package is enough to give the American sports car the edge in terms of raw acceleration, but it’s not that much in it.
So, which of the two would an American motorhead with a declared passion for Corvettes recommend? Believe it or not, it’s a tough one to call. RacerX naturally leans toward the C8, but he makes it very clear that you won’t go wrong with either of them. At the end of the day, it’s all about priorities – better acceleration and that fighter jet cockpit feel, or better interior quality and a more refined ride that’s suitable for long drivers? Of course, even if they do cost the same to buy, maintenance is going to be more expensive on the Porsche, so keep that in mind as well.
"Boy meets car, boy loves car, boy gets journalism degree and starts job writing and editing at a car magazine" - 5/5. (Vlad Mitrache if he was a movie) Full profile
Would you like AUTOEVOLUTION to send you notifications?
Google News