2021 Nissan Rogue vs Mazda CX-5: What's the Best Crossover for $38,000?

Compact crossovers now have nearly everything, from cool design to practicality and features. The comparison between this CX-5 and Rogue echoes the rivalry between almost any Mazda and Nissan. And by that, we mean the Kodo brand intentionally targets "soul," compromising on some of the specs that might seem appealing on paper.

The two white vehicles in this TFL comparison review both strive to get $38,000 from customers but do this in different ways. For example, this being a CX-5 Signature AWD, it gets the optional 2.5-liter turbo engine making 227 horsepower (250 hp on premium gas) and 310 lb-ft of torque. But where it gets 24 mpg combined, the Nissan gets 28 mpg. And that's because the new Rogue is equipped with a 2.5-liter four-cylinder (no turbo) making 181 hp and 181 lb-ft.

Are you willing to trade power for efficiency? Well, we feel that most crossover buyers aren't looking for fun, but the CX-5 is just so difficult to walk away from, especially with that bold grille and curvy shoulder lines. Being an all-new model, the 2021 Rogue isn't too shabby either. But its style seems to be concentrated in those split headlights.

Much like other Mazdas, the CX-5 isn't the best when it comes to practicality, which has to do with legroom and the curvy back cutting into the trunk. The Rogue's trunk has more versatility and holds about 6 cubic feet more, which could be a big deal.

Nissan has really upped its game in the interior department. The new Rogue has better infotainment, a bigger sunroof, and more comfortable seats, at least according to TFL. Is that stuff important to you crossover buyers in 2021?