Pedigree of the brands - A Different View of the Story... ...Many of us own cars which come from rather famous brands. Plenty of times, even if you hate to admit it, the badge is the main reason to look at a certain car and, in the end, it's the decisive reason in actually choosing the "perfect"model. OK, there ... Continue reading >
LATEST LOG ENTRIES:
QUICK STATS:
Test Drive: MINI Cooper S Cabrio - 2009
Table of contents:
- PHOTO GALLERY
- INTRO / HISTORY / BRAND
- EXTERIOR
- INTERIOR
- IN THE CITY
- OPEN ROAD
- COMFORT
- TECH FACTS
- GADGETS
- SAFETY
- CONCLUSIONS
- GUEST EDITOR OPINIONS
SEPTEMBER 2009
INTRO / HISTORY / BRAND 8/10
With the first ever car rolling off the production line in 1959, under a company which no longer exists, the Mini can be viewed as one of the true survivors in the automotive industry. "What a birthday! It's Mini!" A somewhat odd tag line which came about this year to celebrate half a decade of Mini. So, one of the biggest automotive icons of the British has finally turned fifty. A nice, round number, for that matter.
Of course, many things have changed with the Mini over the years. First of all, it's been manufactured under the auspices of quite a hefty number of brands, finally settling under the BMW umbrella in 1994. Second of all, the space-saving layout of the original car wasn't exactly preserved to modern times and the car slowly transformed from a cheap means of transportation for the masses in a cultural icon on wheels.
Not to say that this is a bad thing, since Mini now stands for a thoroughbred driving enthusiast's automobile. Driving enthusiasts, young females and gay male hair dressers, as a matter of fact. And yes, that is quite a motley bunch of Mini customers, we agree.
Since 2009 is a year of celebration for Mini as a brand/model, we though we'd also do something about it. We only succeeded in attending the Mini birthday party held at the Frankfurt Auto Show though, and on top of that we didn't even bring any present. To make matters worse, we also trashed in a very unholy way one of their products. We're exaggerating about the "trashing" part by the way, but to tell you guys the truth, this was one of the most fun cars we ever took for a test drive.
A mustard-yellow Mini Cooper S Cabrio with black racing stripes and black rims, need we say more? Why yes we do, but you'll find out more about our opinion about the little bugger in each of the test drive chapters bellow.
 |  |  |  |  |
VISUAL IMPACT (EXTERIOR) 7/10
As pretty much everyone knows, the original Mini was designed in the late 1950s by Sir Alec Issigonis. Even though it was quite a good-looking "destroyer of German bubble cars", as his makers from the British Motor Corporation envisioned it, the first ever Mini was far from being a "cool" car, at least by today's standards.
Read more >>
Its design was pure "form follows function", with the project's main idea being that its passenger area would take approximately 80% of the car's total length. Every other design detail followed the same "road", with the hinges for the doors and boot lid being mounted externally to reduce costs, while the welded seams for the unibody were visible from the outside.
After taking over the MG-Rover Group in 1994, which also included the Mini sub-brand, BMW came up with the idea of making a "new Mini" which would bring modernism following a similar line of design as its predecessors.
After two mildly-intriguing but commercially unfeasible concept cars with tonnes of retro lines, BMW finally came up with a modern successor in 2001. Penned by Frank Stephenson, the first generation of the new Mini (now MINI) captured a lot of hearts from day one, managing to keep the basic lines of the original while adding a nice touch of modern ones. Here we are, eight years later, testing the Mark II generation of the new Mini, which at first looks as if it's only a slightly restyled version of the one drawn by Frank Stephenson.
Although first impressions usually count, we were surprised to see there are quite a few subtle differences, most of the coming from the fact that there isn't a single body panel identical to the one from 2001. It keeps and actually improves the previous generations' bulldog stance while managing to look very modern.
Such a large amount of chrome on a car so small would be blasphemy by most of today's standards. Oddly, it really works on the Mini, although some fans might be a little upset upon finding it's actually "plastic chrome". Obviously, the plastic is there for pedestrian safety reasons, not because Mini guys are cheapskates.
Since we got to test a Cooper S version, which was also fitted with some special extras, our car was even more good-looking than your average Convertible Mini. Sports-looking black-painted rims on all four corners of the car and two black racing stripes adorned its short and bulgy hood. The Cooper S version also ads a new front bumper and a hood intercooler intake which makes the car look even more "butch".
The side is obviously better-looking with the top down, while the rear is quasi-identical to the Mini from 2001, minus the exterior-mounted hinges for the petit luggage compartment. This last missing feature was of course harking back to the original Mini, and its disappearance actually makes the new one look less retro. We wonder if the Mark III and IV generations will transform the Mini line of design into a Porsche 911-like evolution though. Overall, the Mini Cooper S Cabrio is one good-looking convertible with almost perfect proportions for such a small car.
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
DEEP IMPACT (INTERIOR) 7/10
First thing when stepping inside our test car was to be (once again) amazed by the sheer size of the speedometer, mounted right in the top part of the center console. We realize the reason for its positions is strictly for retro reasons, so that it can be as similar to the original as possible, by the way. What we don't get is why it has to be sized the same as a cooking pan. Plus, when driving it with the top down pretty much everyone on the road can learn of your exact speed just by glancing towards your car. Not to mention every single one of your (maximum three) passengers.
Which brings us to the interior space, specially made to cure any agoraphobic upon entering it while the top is up. The overall space in the front is decent, although your elbows might feel a little "constrained" by the fact you'll always bump them from something inside the car if you're a larger fellow. The two seats in the rear are an entirely different experience altogether though.
Even if Mini's marketing says this is a 2+2 car, there is no way in hell you can fit four grown people inside it for a trip taking more than a few hundred yards, since most of the passengers will probably hate your guts for it. The luggage compartment is also only useful if you're traveling light, the Indian way. In other words, it's fit for a couple of briefcases and a backpack, with only 170 liters (6 cubic feet) of space.
Now, leaving the overall space aside, our test car's interior was quite a feast for a retro-geek's eyes. There are classically-shaped buttons and knobs everywhere on the car, while the overall design also harks back to "the good old days" of motoring.
Although at first it might appear a bit cluttered with buttons, the center console has easy to use and find controls and the materials used are much more "premium" than your average small econobox. A nice touch is of course the way the rev counter sits right behind the steering wheel alone, only to be "bothered" by a feature which can't be found on any other car's list of options. It's a small clock-like thingy called the "Always-Open Timer". In other words, it's a stop watch which tells you how long the roof has stayed open.
There is no actual purpose for it to stay right up there with the tachometer, but we kind of "digged" the idea behind its existence. To sum up the overall ambient in our test car in just a few words, it would sound something like this: cozy, cramped, sporty, retro and elegant. We should also further add that you can personalize your Mini's interior in just about every way possible, switching through a huge palette of colors and materials.
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |
IN THE CITY 5/10
Just like the Alfa MiTo we tested earlier, the Mini Cooper s Cabrio is also penalized by the extremely low ground clearance in the front. By default, this car is an enemy of potholes, speed bumps and roadside curbs. Actually, these are the car's major downsides in the city. Those and the fact that with the top up there is absolutely no way for you to see something behind you.
Read more >>
Thankfully, the exterior rear view mirrors, albeit with a funky oval design, are more than decently-sized and, on top of that, our test car had both front and rear parking sensors. That, corroborated with the fact that the Mini is just what its name implies, Mini, almost makes parking in the city a breeze.
We got the chance to test a de-tuned version of 1.6-liter turbocharged mill under the hood in a Citroen C4 Coupe we tested before, and we have to say we were more than impressed with the one in the Mini also. The nice and beefy torque band is present almost on the whole rev-range, which makes city-driving as comfortable and as pleasurable as possible from the "switching gears point of view."
Although it's an engine with over 100 horsepower per liter, almost unheard of on a road car in the times when the original Mini was leaving the factory, the turbocharged four-banger is quite economical. During our test drive in a city with busy traffic we managed to achieve around 10 liters per 100 kilometers (US 23.5 mpg), which isn't half bad considering it has a 175-horsepower gasoline engine that can deliver quite a lot of punch.
We believe that in regular traffic, without endless lines of cars at each traffic light and intersection, the official 8.1 liters per 100 kilometers (US 29 mpg) can actually be achieved. We also should mention that, besides the direct injection system and the twin-scroll turbocharger, the new Mini Cooper S Cabrio also benefits from BMW's "stop/start" feature, which we kept disabled most of the time since the traffic we encountered didn't allow the said technology to actually help fuel consumption.
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |
OPEN ROAD 8/10
Almost everyone knows by now that the new-Mini handles like a go-kart. Well, hear it from someone is something, but to actually experience it on a twisted mountain road is something else. As far as we're concerned, the Mini Cabrio in Cooper S guise is one of the most fabulous front-wheel drive cars ever when it comes to handling.
Read more >>
We managed to drive it both on stretches of highway and on a serpentine mountain road and we must say that it was one of the most fun we ever had with our pants on. The steering is precise and offers enormous feedback (maybe too much at times), while the multi-link suspension on all four corners keeps the car planted no matter how hard you try to defy the laws of physics in a corner.
On top of that, the sound the exhaust makes when you shift through the gears with the top down is absolutely pandemic for your hearing. Our test car was also fitted with a "Sport" button (which obviously remained pressed for the whole period), which actually makes the steering sportier and the howls and barks of the exhaust even louder.
There's also a "boom-boom-boom" kind of sound every time you take your foot off the accelerator to change gears. Speaking of which, the six-speed manual transmission is almost flawless and the gear ratios are low enough to always keep you in the power band, thus providing neck-snapping acceleration. OK, the Cooper S isn't THAT fast in a straight line, but the rather high amount of torque available on tap is enough to provide quite a lot of racy sensations.
The naught to 100 kilometers per hour acceleration (62 mph) takes 7.4 seconds, which isn't extremely fast for today's "sports car standards", but it's more than enough to scare your passengers. Our test car wasn't fitted with the optional limited slip differential though, which kind of made any attempt to "kick it" from standing still pretty futile.
Because of the enormous (for such a small engine) maximum torque of 240 Nm (177 lb ft) available from as low as 1600 rpm all the way to 5000 rpm, the car would jolt from left to right whenever we tried to accelerate harder from low speeds. The engine also has an over-boost feature, which increases the maximum torque by 20 Nm (14.8 lb ft) for a limited amount of time.
The fuel consumption after a ride in the "twisties" jumped pretty high though, almost 12 liters per 100 kilometers (US 19.6 mpg). You shouldn't fret though, the soon as we hit constant highway speeds it dropped to a quite reasonable figure of 6.5 liters per 100 kilometers (US 36.2 mpg). As a side conclusion, if we were to buy a Cooper S Cabrio we would most likely do it just for driving it on a twisted mountain road with the top down, since the amount of thrills it can provide is probably the next best thing to sex, drugs or other endorphin-inducing substances.
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |
FEED ME LIES (COMFORT) 3/10
We would lie if we were to say this is the most comfortable car we have ever driven. To put it simply, it's actually far from it. A badly paved road is probably the last thing on which you should drive the Mini Cooper S Cabrio, since the limited amount of suspension travel, the sports shocks and the fact that it's a pretty small car with a short wheelbase do everything to compress your spine.
Read more >>
The whole vehicle simply dances over every speed bump or pothole and at times it can actually make you think you're trying to ride a wild horse instead of driving a car. The run-flat tires don't help the ride comfort either. If it wasn't obvious enough, the go-kart handling does have its toll. You shouldn't imagine it's like a racing car though, as on decent roads the Mini does keep its composure well enough.
The seats are also a bit hard but they do provide a very good side support thanks to the ergonomic side bolsters. Plus, they were drenched in leather. Larger drivers should be wary though, as they're not exactly fit for a wrestler. As far as other comfort areas, the Mini we drove was actually doing quite well. The automatically retractable soft top has the switch all the way on top of the interior rear view mirror though. Not exactly a hard to reach spot, but the thing is you have to keep it pressed for the whole duration of the car's "unveiling".
Other than that, the automatic single-zone climate control does its fair job at keeping the bad weather out, so do the three-stage heated front seats, especially since Mini's marketing people are actually daring you to drive the car "always open". The petite wind deflector is also a nice addition, especially since its completely foldable and doesn't use much of the already small luggage compartment.
 |  |  |  |  |
DEUS EX MACHINA (TECH FACTS) 6/10
The 1.6-litter powerplant in the Mini Cooper S Cabrio sure doesn't impress with its displacement. What it does impress though is the amount of modern technology used on it and its efficiency. Unlike the Mark I BMW Mini, this one doesn't use a supercharger but a small twin-scroll turbocharger to pump out no less than 175 horsepower and 240 Nm (173 lb ft) of torque available on a gigantic rev band (from 1600 rpm to 5000 rpm).
Built in a join-venture between BMW and the PSA Group, the small four-cylinder also uses a direct injection system and fully variable valve timing, features which deliver more grunt, less fuel consumption and less emissions. All in one small package.
The newly-developed six-speed manual transmission is well cogged and has all (including the reverse) gears synchronized to provide quite a crisp and precise gear change. Also on the plus side, the soft top is fully automatized in standard meaning you only have to use a button for it to open or close in just 21 seconds. Those seconds do transform in about 24 if the engine is switched off though, for reasons we didn't exactly get.
On the whole, the Mini Cooper S Cabrio is one technologically capable car. Especially for a vehicle its size, there's not much more techy bits you could have in other models.
USEFUL TOYS (GADGETS) 7/10
As far as the amount of gadgetry present on our test car, we couldn't have asked for more. Night time visibility was more than adequate thanks to the Xenon/HID headlights, aided by the light sensors. Windshield wipers were also aided by sensors. Unlike its hart top brother though, the Cooper S Cabrio doesn't have a rear wiper (how could it?) and visibility towards the rear during rain or when the window is dirty may be a little compromised.
We also had three-stage heated seats, a very capable single-zone climate control system and a pretty good in-dash CD-player with MP3 capabilities and an auxiliary port for your iPod. Another feature which we found useful was the fact that the rear side-windows can be fully opened or closed by a single button on the center console.
Also, the leather-wrapped three spoke steering wheel was fitted with pretty helpful button to control some functions of the on-board computer, the audio system and the fully active automatic speed regulator. Apart from that, our car was also fitted with keyless entry, which is nice most of time, unless you're a forgetful person and tend to lose keys.
Beside the... let's say average sound system, all of the features present on our test car usually belong on slightly larger, more upscale models. The only useful gadget missing from it was probably a satellite navigation system, which normally would have stayed inside the ginormous speedometer.
 |  |  |  |  |
ON THE SAFE SIDE (SAFETY) 8/10
Of course, just by taking a short glance at a car that would look more appropriate in a child's bedroom and with a remote you're not exactly convinced it's actually safe. Well, according to some the international crash testing organizations it really is. Whether it has five stars out of five at the EuroNCAP or a "good" rating at the IIHS, the Mini is among the safest cars in its class.
Naturally, crash ratings aren't enough for some people, so we should also add that the Cooper S Cabrio we drove cam equipped with an anti-lock braking system, electronic stability control and cornering brake control. If there are still people who aren't convinced we should also add the standard dual-stage frontal airbags and the side airbags as well.
Yeah, but it's a convertible, what happens if you roll over, it doesn't even have a proper roll bar, you might ask? Well, it does have a proper roll bar, two of them actually. Both are connected and are sitting in expectation tucked in behind the rear seat. They will pop up as soon as the roll-over sensors detect there's an impetuous possibility for the car to turn with the shiny side down.
THE GOOD, THE BAD AND THE UGLY (CONCLUSIONS) 8/10
The best part about the Mini Cooper S Cabrio we drove has got to be its exceptional handling prowess. There is simply not a chance you will ever be the same after driving one through the twisties. Whenever driving on serpentine roads it's like having your own personal roller coaster, which you can control. Everything from the absolutely fantastic ride and the sharp steering ratio, to the wide track and the hair-rising exhaust sound can actually change your perception about how a small car should handle. In short, this is a grown man's boy toy.
As for the bad, we could only decide on the downside of having such good handling. The suspension setup is stiff, the shocks travel is short, the tires are hard run-flats... you get the point. The comfort is almost gone, as long as you don't drive on mirror-like roads on a daily basis. It simply isn't a car which you can live 24/7 or take for longer journeys for two reasons: its lack of suspension comfort over not-so-good roads and the fact that you can't fit too much luggage in it.
The ugly bit about the Cooper S Cabrio is probably the fact that its niche is too small. It's not exactly a car for daily driving (unless some conditions are met), which kind of only makes it fit as a second or even a third car. Its slogan is "always open", but it should probably be "open only during the weekend, since you're driving your other car during the rest of the week." If you're gunning for a special car to be used only for driving fun, this should be one of the top picks though.
GUEST STAR EDITORS' OPINIONS AND RATINGS
| Sir May B. Bach strongly believes this car is worthy of a rating of 4 / 10 "You know I've always said that if something is good-looking with the top on, it should be a thousand times better with its... ahem... top off. Not to mention when talking about... ahem... cars. Now, if something is crappy with its top on... ahem... we shouldn't even discuss about its “naked” version." Read more >> |
| Charles Darveight pondered gravely, nearly fell asleep and then submitted a rating of 6 / 10 "A convertible Mini, which is proudly wearing an “S” badge, can considered a modern work of art. It can offer profound and visceral sporty sensations with the help of just a precise steering, a very wide track, good side bolster support in the seats, blah blah bla. Sounds good?" Read more >> |
| Mary broke a nail, complained a bit and then gave a rating of 9 / 10 "OMG I hate you guys! Why did you ever leave me around a cute little car like this? From the moment I stepped inside it I knew this is the right car for a lady like myself. The mustard-yellow color, the racing stripes on the hood, the black wheels, the retro motifs all around the exterior and the interior... everything looks and feels perfect!" Read more >> |
| Lou Cheeka knocked, knocked some more and finally shouted a rating of 2 / 10 "I gotta say that I did bring a lot of doubts to this test drive. When I heard I was about to drive a Mini Cabriolet, Cooper S or not, a special alert was triggered in my brain. A gay alert. Not to say that I'm a homophobe or anything, but I have to state clearly that I am a straight male. I only like girls, mkay?" Read more >> |
Read by 19,898 users |
Add comment |
Print |
Send to friend
30.09.2009 | 00:04 GMT
very nice car
30.09.2009 | 09:38 GMT
Beauty and beast...
02.10.2009 | 06:11 GMT
great value.
05.10.2009 | 05:14 GMT
i want that car :-(
09.10.2009 | 08:26 GMT
Perfect
10.10.2009 | 12:31 GMT
Congrats and thank you for this well written and senseful drive test... I've just bought that car, I'll tell you...
13.11.2009 | 14:20 GMT
I own one and I am quite happy with it !
21.11.2009 | 04:25 GMT
Have had the cabriolet S as a loner (BMW put our mini through a car wash with the windows down) for a week and love it. Unfortunately it's the automatic and unless it's in sports mode there is quite a lag between putting your foot down and any action. Normally I have continued to put my foot down as nothing has happened and then all of a sudden I'm shooting down the road. If you are going to get this car (highly recommended) do yourself a favour and get the manual. In my opinion a car of this ability should always be in manual anyway.